
Michelle E. Cafaro
Physician Assistant in Loudonville, NY
- Enrolled in Medicare
- Offers telehealth
- 17 years since graduation
- Public record — not managed by the clinician
About Michelle Cafaro
Michelle Cafaro is a physician assistant practicing in Loudonville, NY, a graduate of Albany Medical College of Union University (2009). Records list 2 practice addresses. Affiliated with Ellis Hospital, Samaritan Hospital, St Peter's Hospital and 1 more. Treated 174 Medicare patients in 2024.
- Physician Assistant
- Oldendorf Medical Services, PLLC
- Enrolled in Medicare
- In-person visits at 2 addresses
- Offers telehealth
Provider details
| Specialty | Physician AssistantOther physician assistants in Loudonville |
|---|---|
| Education | Albany Medical College of Union University, 2009CMS Doctors and Clinicians |
| Gender | Female |
| NPI number | 1619205655National Provider Identifier (CMS NPPES), issued December 2009 |
| Medicare | Enrolled in MedicareCMS Doctors and Clinicians |
| Telehealth | Offers telehealth servicesCMS Doctors and Clinicians |
Michelle Cafaro's specialties and state licenses
- Physician Assistant Primary
License: NY 013769-1
As reported by the clinician to the NPPES registry. Confirm a license and any disciplinary history with the state medical or licensing board.
Where Michelle Cafaro practices
-
Oldendorf Medical Services, PLLC 407 Albany Shaker Rd, Suite 100, Loudonville, NY 12211 (518) 435-1300 Group of 7 clinicians Directions Call office View clinic details -
Loretto Adult Community, Inc. 1301 Nottingham Rd, Jamesville, NY 13078 (315) 413-3600 Group of 301 clinicians Directions Call office View clinic details
Addresses from CMS Doctors and Clinicians (Medicare enrollment). Call before visiting: a clinician may not see patients at every listed address.
Hospital affiliations of Michelle Cafaro
- Ellis HospitalHospital · Schenectady, NY
- Samaritan HospitalHospital · Troy, NY
- St Peter's HospitalHospital · Albany, NY
- Community Hospice, Inc, theHospice · Albany, NY
CMS Facility Affiliation data: facilities where the clinician bills Medicare.
Michelle Cafaro's Medicare patients and services (2024)
Most frequent services
| Service | Times | Avg. Medicare allowed |
|---|---|---|
| Visit complexity inherent to evaluation and management associated with medical care services that serve as the continuing focal point for all needed health care services and/or with medical care services that are part of ongoing care related to a patient's | 200 | $13.01 |
| Established patient office or other outpatient visit with moderate level of decision making, if using time, 30 minutes or more | 124 | $101.37 |
| Established patient office or other outpatient visit with low level od decision making, if using time, 20 minutes or more | 95 | $72.73 |
| Annual wellness visit, includes a personalized prevention plan of service (pps), subsequent visit | 85 | $104.56 |
| Hemoglobin a1c level | 68 | $9.52 |
| Annual depression screening, 5 to 15 minutes | 65 | $15.16 |
| Administration of a standardized, evidence-based social determinants of health risk assessment tool, 5-15 minutes | 42 | $15.26 |
| Annual wellness visit; includes a personalized prevention plan of service (pps), initial visit | 15 | $133.15 |
Common conditions among these patients
Medicare Part B fee-for-service claims only (CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners, 2024). Patients with private insurance or Medicare Advantage are not counted; small counts are suppressed by CMS. This describes the patients, not the quality of care.
Payments from drug and device companies to Michelle Cafaro (2025)
$720.67 in 32 general payments reported in 2025.
| Type | Payments | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Food and beverage | 32 | $720.67 |
Paying companies: Phathom Pharmaceuticals, Inc. ($149), AbbVie Inc. ($87.90), Sumitomo Pharma America, Inc. ($49.79), Otsuka America Pharmaceutical, Inc. ($46.61), Indivior Inc. ($41.29), Lilly USA, LLC ($37.88).
Reported by companies under the federal Open Payments program (CMS, program year 2025). A payment, such as a meal at an educational event, does not mean wrongdoing; clinicians can dispute records with CMS.
Also at Oldendorf Medical Services, PLLC
- Joseph E. Naas, DPMPodiatry Loretto Adult Community, Inc.
- Jonathan Gainor, MDOrthopedic Surgery OrthoNY
- Matthew R. Brand, MDOrthopedic Surgery Arnot Medical Services PLLC
- Dionisio Ortiz Iii, MDOrthopedic Surgery Capital Region Orthopaedic Associates, PC
- Jeffrey Geller, MDOrthopedic Surgery Loretto Adult Community, Inc.
- Matthew Tetreault, MDOrthopedic Surgery Capital Region Orthopaedic Associates, PC
Questions about Michelle Cafaro
What kind of clinician is Michelle Cafaro?
Michelle Cafaro is listed as a physician assistant.
Where does Michelle Cafaro practice?
Oldendorf Medical Services, PLLC at 407 Albany Shaker Rd, Suite 100, Loudonville, NY 12211, and 1 other address in the records.
What is the office phone number for Michelle Cafaro?
The listed office number is (518) 435-1300. Call to confirm availability and whether new patients are accepted.
What is the NPI number of Michelle Cafaro?
The National Provider Identifier is 1619205655.
Does Michelle Cafaro accept Medicare?
CMS lists this clinician as enrolled in Medicare. Ask the office about assignment and your plan.
Which hospitals is Michelle Cafaro affiliated with?
Ellis Hospital, Samaritan Hospital, St Peter's Hospital, Community Hospice, Inc, the.
Where did Michelle Cafaro go to medical school?
Albany Medical College of Union University, graduating in 2009.
Where this information comes from
| CMS Doctors and Clinicians | Name, specialty, education, Medicare enrollment and practice addresses.Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, national downloadable file (2026) |
|---|---|
| NPPES NPI registry | NPI, specialties (taxonomy) and state licenses.CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System; record updated 2017-06-07 |
| Facility affiliations | Hospitals and other facilities.CMS Doctors and Clinicians facility affiliation file; names from CMS Provider of Services |
| Medicare utilization | Patients, services and conditions.CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners, 2024 |
| Open Payments | Payments from drug and device companies.CMS Open Payments, program year 2025 |
Information is public record and may lag behind changes. Clinicians update it through NPPES and Medicare PECOS. See something wrong? Tell us.
Need an appointment?
Call Oldendorf Medical Services, PLLC at (518) 435-1300 or visit the clinic page to check availability.