Mercieca urges doctors to put patients first in clinic testing dispute

The health committee chair says point-of-care tests could help clinicians assess risk, while the doctors’ association warns they may delay care and increase waiting times.

Mercieca urges doctors to put patients first in clinic testing dispute cottonbro studio

Franco Mercieca, chair of Malta’s parliamentary health committee, has urged doctors and health officials to resolve their dispute over new testing equipment at health centres, saying patient interests must come first. The dispute concerns point-of-care testing (POCT), which provides test results at or near the place where a patient receives care.

The Medical Association of Malta registered an industrial dispute with Primary Health Care Management in August. It says it is concerned the tests could delay treatment for people with potentially serious conditions, including chest pain, if they attend a health centre instead of going directly to hospital. The association has also warned that testing could add to waits at already overstretched centres and has called for training initiatives to be suspended.

Mercieca said representatives of the association, Primary Health Care officials and the chair of Mater Dei Hospital’s emergency department addressed the committee on November 18. Health Minister Ian Borg said earlier in November that the plans would proceed despite doctors’ reservations. No implementation timetable is stated.

Why the testing is disputed

The association’s concern is that a patient who needs emergency care might undergo testing at a health centre before being referred to an emergency department. It argues that testing could prolong the visit and increase waiting times. It has said its safety concerns cannot be addressed through a training session alone.

Mercieca argued that POCT is not a replacement for an emergency department and does not mean patients with chest pain should remain at a health centre. He said that, when used under adequate clinical protocols, the tests can give primary-care doctors results within minutes to help assess risk, choose treatment and decide whether to transfer a patient, without delaying an urgent transfer.

Inquiry recommendation and next steps

Mercieca pointed to recommendations from a board of inquiry into a death in August 2024, chaired by Judge Emeritus Joseph David Camilleri. The board noted that such tests should be available in primary care. Mercieca said safety, training and service organisation concerns should be addressed with practical solutions rather than blocking the technology.

The association’s objections remain part of the dispute, while the government’s plan to introduce the equipment is set to go ahead, according to Borg. The account does not specify when testing will begin or describe any agreement on training, clinical protocols or how the competing concerns will be resolved.

This report draws on information from Times of Malta.

Editorial checks passed Facts, figures and quotes checked against 1 source

Add Clinic Near Me as a preferred source on Google

Related stories